RecipesHomemade Old Fashioned Tasty Tomato Pie Recipe

Homemade Old Fashioned Tasty Tomato Pie Recipe

This homemade old fashioned tasty tomato pie recipe is a delicious way to use your over abundant crop of tomatoes. It’s fair to say you grow a fine crop and your family and community adore your cooking, but wait until they get a load of this drool inducing show stopper- a glorious, flavorful, farm to table tomato pie.

I hope you don’t get writer’s cramp from giving out the recipe.

Homemade Old Fashioned Tasty Tomato Pie Recipe

Make sure you like The Homestead Survival on Facebook, Shop AMAZON with Us and explore our  PINTEREST BOARDS  for innovative ways you can become self-sufficient on a budget.

You poured over seed catalogs, agonizing over the choices, then placed your orders. Your heirloom seeds arrived and you dove into the greenhouse to start them. You couldn’t wait for the soil to warm enough to get them in the ground, praying all the while you were planting that you really had seen the last frost of the season. You watered, you waited, you waited some more, and then one day it happens- those glorious plump tomato beauties are ready to pick.


large tomatoes

basil leaves

green onions

pre-baked deep dish pie shell

sharp cheddar cheese

mozzarella cheese


Salt and pepper


Summer’s bounty has been plentiful again and the tomatoes are bursting with color and flavor. You’ve made traditional sandwiches with thick slices of beefsteak tomatoes on homemade white bread with just the right amount of mayo, beautiful platters of caprese salad with ripe juicy Brandywines contrasting beautifully against artisan mozzarella slices splayed out like nature’s dominoes, sprinkled with basil fresh from the kitchen garden and drizzled with organic olive oil and a nice thick balsamic vinegar.

You’ve reduced bushels of meaty romas into grandma’s famous spaghetti sauce and fried up cornmeal coated green tomatoes and enjoyed every bite. Neighbors crave your fresh tomato salsa, and the recipe for your homemade ketchup has been requested so many times you take a stack of pre-made recipe cards with you to all the potlucks it goes to.

Click here to read about how to make a homemade old fashioned tasty tomato pie recipe:

[amazon-related-products keywords=”pie dish, Pioneer Woman 9 Inch Stoneware Pie Dish, Ceramics Rooster Pie FunnelPie Plate with Cardinal Pie Bird“]


Melissa Francis
Melissa Francis
Greetings! I'm Melissa Francis, the founder and primary contributor to The Homestead Survival. With over 20 years of experience in homesteading, sustainability, and emergency preparedness, I've dedicated my life to helping others achieve a simpler, more self-reliant lifestyle.

Subscribe Today


Get unlimited access to our EXCLUSIVE Content and our archive of subscriber stories.

Exclusive content

Latest articles

Popular Articles

More articles